Donations from readers like you allow us to do what we do. Please help us continue our work with a monthly or one-time donation.

Donate Today

Subscribe Today

Subscribe to receive daily or weekly MEMRI emails on the topics that most interest you.

Request a Clip

Media, government, and academia can request a MEMRI clip or other MEMRI research, or ask to consult with or interview a MEMRI expert.
Request Clip
Oct 23, 2020
Share Video:

Official Chinese TV Criticizes U.S. Capitalism, Trump's Economic Policies: The Government Should Redistribute Wealth; Fundamental Reforms Are The Only Solution; Trump Does Not Care About Making America Great Again

#8385 | 03:17
Source: CGTN Network (China)

On October 23, 2020, an English-language animated video titled "Political Expediency Trumps U.S. Good" was posted on the YouTube channel of China's CGTN Network. The narrator criticized U.S. President Donald Trump's economic and global policies, saying that President Trump is pandering to voters and to a wealthy elite by lowering taxes and by blaming America's economic problems on emerging economies. The narrator argued, however, that America's problems are caused by the wealth gap, which he said is the inevitable result of America's capitalist economy and of laissez-faire economic policies. He said that governments are responsible for the redistribution of wealth, but that Trump is irresponsible and would rather benefit politically than actually make America great. The narrator added that "fundamental reforms" are the only solution to America's economic problems.


Narrator: "The United States' dominant role in international bodies is becoming history. Since taking office, Donald Trump has withdrawn the country from global pact after global pact. He claims the exists were part of his pursuit of Making America Great Again. This is an excuse. They are acts of political expediency. Why? Have a look at the income gap. In 2018, the richest 10% of American households held 70% of total household wealth, up from 60% in 1989. The lower and middle class saw, 'essentially zero net gains in wealth' over the past 30 years. Their share of total wealth went down to just 1 percent from 4 percent.


This is an inevitable result of the U.S. system. A minority of people hold a majority of the total wealth. Former President Franklin Roosevelt understood the problem and his New Deal temporarily helped alleviate the wealth disparity. But the Reagan Era saw an upsurge of neoliberalism and laissez-faire economic policies revived the income gap. No effective solution has been introduced since.

"Fast forwarding into the 21st century, American businesses were quick to move factories do developing countries. The cost of hiring a factory worker for one day in Argentina is 26% that of the United States. The corresponding numbers are 23 percent in Brazil, 13 percent in Mexico, and 4 percent in the Philippines. Making profits is what capitalism is all about. But this has been at the sacrifice of blue-collar workers at home, as the shrinking factory sector inevitably led to job losses. Trump's solution to the income disparity is the blame game. He has neglected the consequences of capitalism and attributed the U.S. economic problems to emerging economies.

"This is why the president has waged global tariff fights, and frantically pulled his country from global pacts. This style of capitalism, not globalization, is the root cause of the income gap. Fundamental reforms are the only solution. But Trump believes any attempt to redistribute the social wealth will harm American financial cliques. And the president's attitude on tax demonstrates his desperation for the plutocracy's support. After his 2017 tax cut, the 400 wealthiest Americans paid a lower total tax rate than any other income group last year.

"But Trump cannot ignore his grassroots supporters' concerns. Blaming globalization is an easy way out. He does not have to worry about moving his sponsors' cheese and saying no to international responsibilities helps woo blue-collar voters bearing grudges against globalization. This is irresponsible and is not a cure. Any government has the duty to help redistribute wealth. Shelving the problem only makes it worse. Trump knows it. But his political career apparently carries much more weight, then making America great again."

Share this Clip: