Egyptian Cleric Samir Hashish: No Death Penalty for a Muslim Who Kills a Non-Muslim; The Blood of Muslims Is More Important
During a January 7, 2017 address at the Al-Khulafa Al-Rashideen Mosque in Sixth of October City near Cairo, Egyptian cleric Samir Hashish referred to a hadith in Sahih Al-Bukhari that says that Muslims should not be put to death for killing infidels, and he said that some people use this hadith to justify killing non-Muslims. He explained that this is a distortion of the hadith, which actually only means that the death penalty may not be applied in such cases, while other punishments should still be applied. He added that Muslims are not put to death for killing infidels because their blood is worth more. The video was recently posted online.
Following are excerpts:
Samir Hashish: There is a hadith that says: "No Muslim may be killed for killing an infidel." Some people say that a Muslim who perpetrates a crime in a house of worship of non-Muslim has nothing to worry about, because a hadith in Sahih Al-Bukhari exempts him from punishment and justifies his deed. In other words, he perpetrates this act because he believes that it is permitted by the hadith that says: "No Muslim may be killed for killing an infidel." Obviously, this is a deception.
So what's the story behind this hadith? It doesn't mean that if someone kills a person from the People of the Book unjustly, he is committing a legitimate act. That's not what the hadith means. The hadith does not say that this is a legitimate act. The hadith merely excludes the death penalty from the possible punishments. If a Muslim kills a non-Muslim without a legitimate reason… Is he wrong to do so? Yes. Should he be punished? Yes. However, he should not be given the death penalty. The judge may give him any deterring punishment in his case, with the exception of the death penalty. Why? Because of the hadith that says that no Muslim may be killed for killing an infidel. Why is that? Because their lives are not worth the same. The blood of Muslims is more important. If you want to call this "racism", fine. Of course the blood of Muslims is more important.