Liberal Indian Islamic Scholar Examines Koranic Injunctions on Family Planning and Pregnancy Termination

"Many people, especially women, have asked me if family planning is permissible in Islam. They say the imams and ulema [Islamic scholars] say the Koran prohibits family planning and quote a verse which says, 'And kill not your children for fear of poverty – we provide for them and for you. Surely the killing of them is a great wrong' [Chapter 17, Verse 31].

"In no way does this verse refer to family planning because it is talking of 'killing,' and you kill one who exists. No law in the world will permit killing one who is already born, and hence the Koran rightly condemns the killing of children. Some people suggest that the verse in question refers to the practice of burying girl children alive, and when asked they would say they could not provide for them and hence Allah responds that He provides for them.

"Imam Razi suggests the verse refers to both male and female children being kept ignorant. Thus killing them has not been used as in killing the body but the mind, which is as bad as killing the body. The word used here is 'awlad' i.e. children, which includes both male and female.

"Imam Razi's suggestion seems to be quite reasonable, and in fact a large family means children cannot be properly educated by poor parents, and hence parents 'kill' them mentally by keeping them ignorant.

"They cannot even clothe them properly, nor can they provide proper living space. In such circumstances one cannot raise quality human beings, and quantity does not matter much. That said, we should understand that at the time of the revelation of the Koran, the problem of family planning did not exist, nor did the need for population control."

"The Koran has Already Mentioned that 'If You Fear Injustice [in Treating Wives] then Marry Only One' Woman"

"It is a modern problem which has arisen in our time. Most nation states in the developing world do not have the economic means to support large populations, and when we say supporting large populations it does not mean only feeding them but also includes education and the provision of proper health services. These are the basic duties of modern nation states.

"In fact, in view of the paucity of resources, it has become necessary to adopt family planning. When the Koran was being revealed there was neither any properly organized state nor education nor health services provided by a state agency.

It is important to note that the Koran, which shows eight ways to spend zakat, does not include education or health, which is so essential for the state to provide today. Thus what Imam Razi suggests is not only very correct but also enhances the importance of family planning in modern times, as a small family can support better education and health services.

"It would be interesting to note that as for verse 4:3 (which is used by Muslims for justification of polygamy) Imam Shafi'i interprets it rather differently. It ends with the words 'alla ta'ulu,' which is generally translated as 'you may not do injustice,' i.e. do not marry more than one woman so that you may not do injustice. But Imam Shafi'i renders it as 'so that you do not have a large family.' The Koran has already mentioned that 'if you fear injustice then marry only one' woman and so there was no need to repeat it. That is why Imam Shafi'i feels it should be translated as 'so that you do not have a large family.'

"It can be seen that in understanding the Koran that even very eminent imams and great scholars differed with one another. One should not impose one single meaning of a verse on all Muslims. The Koran could be interpreted differently by different people in their own context and circumstances, as has historically been the practice. Family planning being a modern need, one should not reject it out of hand and quote Koranic verses out of context."

"Some Scholars Referring to the Verse 23:14 Conclude That One Can Terminate Pregnancy Up to Three Months After Conception"

"Family planning does not mean killing children after they are born, but to plan the birth of children in a way that parents can bear all the expenses for their education, health, living space, upkeep, etc. in a proper manner. The Koran also suggests that a child be suckled for two years, and it is well known that as long as the mother suckles she may not conceive. Thus, indirectly, the Koran suggests spacing between children.

"In hadith [sayings and deeds of Prophet Muhammad] literature, we find that the Prophet (PBUH) permitted prevention of conceiving in certain circumstances. When a person asked the Prophet for permission for 'azl' (withdrawal) as he was going for a long journey along with his wife and he did not wish his wife to conceive, the Messenger of Allah allowed him. In those days this was the only known method for planning the birth of a child. Today there are several more methods available.

"Imam Ghazali allows even termination of pregnancy if the mother's life is in danger and suggests several methods for termination. He even allows termination of pregnancy on health grounds or if the mother's beauty is in danger, provided it is in consultation with her husband.

"Some scholars referring to the verse 23:14 conclude that one can terminate pregnancy up to three months after conception as the Koran, in this verse, describes the stages of development of the sperm planted in the mother's womb; it takes three months for life to begin.

"However, many ulema today oppose the termination of pregnancy. Whatever the case, one cannot declare family planning as prohibited in Islam as it in