memri
December 2, 2010 Special Dispatch No. 3426

Pakistan's Tourism Minister - 'Taliban are the True Followers of Islamic Ideology And America is the Biggest Terrorist of the World'; Pakistani Columnist - 'The Tourism Minister's... Utterances Simply Confirm the Deeply Schizophrenic Country Pakistan has Become'

December 2, 2010
Pakistan | Special Dispatch No. 3426


Image courtesy: pakistanileaders.com.pk

Maulana Attaur Rehman (pictured above) is Pakistan’s Federal Minister for Tourism. He was elected to the National Assembly the lower house of the Pakistani parliament, in the February 2008 elections. Rehman belongs to the Jamiat Ulema-e-Islam (JUI-F), a political-religious party that is part of the federal governing coalition in Pakistan.

While speaking at a public meeting in the Mansehra district of Pakistan’s Khyber Pakhtunkhwa province, the tourism minister recently described the Taliban as the "true followers of Islamic ideology" and dubbed the United States as the world’s "biggest terrorist."

The tourism minister’s comments drew a strong response from liberal Pakistani columnist Irfan Husain, who questioned why Maulana Attaur Rehman, a pro-Taliban orthodox cleric, was given the charge of tourism ministry by President Asif Zardari.

Writing in the Dawn newspaper, Irfan Husain observed: "Normally, if the public views of a minister are so far out of sync with government policy, he is asked to resign. But as far as I can detect, Zardari and his Prime Minister [Yousuf Raza Gilani] show no embarrassment at all over this outburst...."

Following are some excerpts from Maulana Attaur Rehman’s statement:[1]

Tourism Minister: "It is America Which is Against the Interfaith Harmony to Maintain Its Hegemony on the World…"

"Ulema [Islamic scholars] and the Taliban are the true followers of Islamic ideology and America is the biggest terrorist of the world, which is creating hatred against them…"

"The ongoing spate of terrorism cannot be eliminated until the U.S. and the world gives equal rights and respect to the Muslims…"

"It is a misconception that Ulema and the Taliban are against coexistence of people with different religions; in fact it is America which is against the interfaith harmony to maintain its hegemony on the world…"

Following are some excerpts from columnist Irfan Husain’s article:[2]

Pakistani Columnist: "The Minister has Openly and Clearly Stated that Pakistan’s Religious Parties and Their Supporters are On the Same Wavelength as the Taliban"

"I became convinced that [Pakistani President] Asif Zardari had a sense of humour when I first learned of the appointment of Maulana Attaur Rehman as the federal minister for tourism. Who better than this bearded, rotund cleric as the face of Pakistan to attract tourists to our shores? ..."

"I’m glad the minister has openly and clearly stated that Pakistan`s religious parties and their supporters are on the same wavelength as the Taliban. No doubt he supported the Taliban`s Stone Age policies while they were in power: executions, floggings and amputations were among the public entertainment [Taliban leader] Mullah Omar and his gang provided the Afghans.

"What they did not provide was education for girls or progress of any kind. Indeed, women were locked up out of sight, and men’s beards were measured for correct length. Having less facial hair than the prescribed length was a serious offence. Pastimes like flying kites or playing chess were naturally banned, as were music and movies.

"This, then, is the ‘Islamic ideology’ of the Taliban. So what does that make the millions of Muslims around the world who utterly rejected this barbaric system? Lesser Muslims, or even non-Muslims, in the eyes of the Maulana, no doubt."

"Fortunately... Rehman’s Portfolio was Split Up to Accommodate Another Minister; Otherwise He would have Been in Charge of Culture as Well"

"Fortunately for us, Attaur Rehman`s portfolio was split up to accommodate another minister in this bloated cabinet; otherwise he would have been in charge of culture as well. Given his admiration of the Taliban, I can easily imagine him ordering the destruction of the thousands of splendid statues in museums and archaeological sites around the country.

"This, of course, would have mimicked the wanton destruction of the famous giant statues of the Buddha in Bamiyan by the Taliban in 2000. When Mullah Omar ordered this act of cultural and religious desecration, the whole world united in condemning it. In fact, this one show of ignorance and insensitivity lost the Taliban regime any residual sympathy, so when they were thrown out of Kabul in the wake of 9/11, no tears were shed for them.

"The second part of the minister’s rant referred to the Americans. When he demanded that America and the world should give equal rights to Muslims, he was probably unaware that Muslims living in the West enjoy more rights than they do in their own countries. Which is one reason they migrate, legally or illegally, whenever they get an opportunity.

"And when the Maulana said that it is a ‘misconception that the Ulema and the Taliban are against coexistence of people with different religions,’ he should tell that to Aasia Bibi, the Christian woman sentenced to death for alleged blasphemy. Or to her family that has had to go into hiding after being threatened with death by local clerics."

"Zardari and his Prime Minister [Yousuf Raza Gilani] Show no Embarrassment At All over This Outburst"

"Considering that this government is allied with, and dependent on, the United States, it is slightly odd for a cabinet minister to denounce America as ‘the biggest terrorist of the world.’ While this could be his personal view, the public statements of sitting ministers are subjected to greater scrutiny than the ravings of some lone nut out there. Normally, if the public views of a minister are so far out of sync with government policy, he is asked to resign. But as far as I can detect, Zardari and his Prime Minister [Yousuf Raza Gilani] show no embarrassment at all over this outburst...."

"When I looked up Attaur Rehman on the government website, I discovered that last May, he had attended the regional conference of UNWTO [United Nations World Trade Organization] in Hanoi.

"At this gathering of tourism ministers, travel agents and tour operators, he complained that the world media gave a wrong impression of Pakistan through its ‘travel advisories.’ Actually, it is foreign governments that issue these warnings to their citizens in respect of countries where they could be at risk.

"But does he really think the foreign media gives the wrong impression of Pakistan as one of the most dangerous places in the world for outsiders? Considering the daily mayhem we face, as well as the deadly suicide bombings of embassies and hotels that have killed so many foreigners, surely the advisories are based on a grim reality. I suspect the Maulana’s mediaeval figure at the conference must have confirmed everybody`s worst fears about Pakistan. Once again, I must congratulate Zardari for unerringly picking the right man for the right job. Perhaps he should be given the additional portfolio of culture as well."

"The Anti-West, Pro-Taliban Sentiment is the Abiding Image the Rest of the World has of Pakistan"

"Seriously, though, why do we need a tourism ministry at all, apart from giving the job to somebody like Attaur Rehman? We are kidding ourselves if we think that this ministry can or does anything to attract foreign tourists to our country.

"The only foreigners who write ‘tourism’ as the purpose of their visit on their visa applications these days probably come to Pakistan for a few weeks of training in the terrorist camps in the tribal areas. Or they arrive on one-way tickets to enrol for a short course in suicide bombing. For these tourists, the Maulana is an ideal recommendation.

"The tourism minister’s recent utterances simply confirm the deeply schizophrenic country Pakistan has become. We send out simultaneous signals of modernity and mediaevalism, but at the end of the day, the latter drowns out the former. The anti-West, pro-Taliban sentiment is the abiding image the rest of the world has of Pakistan. And as long as people like Attaur Rehman drive the national agenda, politicians like Zardari and Gilani will continue to cave in."

Endnotes:

[1] The Express Tribune (Pakistan), November 24, 2010.

[2] www.dawn.com (Pakistan), November 27, 2010. The text of the article has been lightly edited for clarity.

Share this Report: