Home |Archives |Report #3133

Democratization And Reform In The Arab And Muslim World
 
  Bookmark and Share Text Size
July 30, 2010
Special Dispatch No.3133
Liberal Egyptian Journalist Nabil Sharaf Al-Din Criticizes Muslim Brotherhood Participation in Political Process: You Cannot Play Soccer Using Boxing Rules

Following are excerpts from an interview with Egyptian journalist Nabil Sharaf Al-Din, which aired on Al-Arabiya TV on July 9, 2010.

To view the full clip on MEMRI TV, visit http://www.memritv.org/clip/en/0/0/0/0/0/0/2552.htm.  

Nabil Sharaf Al-Din: "I am not against Islam. I am a Muslim, who bears witness that there is no god but Allah and the Muhammad is His Messenger. By no means am I against Islam. I am against Islamism, against the peddling of the Islamic religion. This is what I mean."

TV host: "Who do you mean by Islamists?"

Nabil Sharaf Al-Din: "The Muslim Brotherhood and its offshoots, the Jihad group and its offshoots, or the Arabs returning from Afghanistan, who later established Al-Qaeda."

TV host: "Why do you have reservations about the Muslim Brotherhood? You always say that you have a problem with people who "leave the door ajar," but the Muslim Brotherhood operate out in the open, they have offices, and they try to participate in the political process. As a liberal, shouldn't you respect the choices of others?"

Nabil Sharaf Al-Din: "Can you play soccer according to the rules of boxing? No, you cannot. Democracy is not merely the ballot box. Democracy is a package deal – take it or leave it. I can run against you, or any other human being, in the elections, but I cannot run against Allah.

"They call themselves the Muslim Brotherhood, and they consider all others to be neither brothers nor Muslims. In this case, religion must be completely severed from politics, because politics is a game of interests while religion is a game of the sacred."

[...]

TV host: "Do you support the [French] legal ban on wearing the niqab?"

Nabil Sharaf Al-Din: "Absolutely. The conditions in the world today... The preventing of harm takes precedence over the achieving of benefit."

TV host: "But doesn't a woman have the right to wear whatever she wants?"

Nabil Sharaf Al-Din: "She is free to do so in her own society, but you cannot impose your culture upon the societies of others."

TV host: "So you support banning the niqab in France, but not in Egypt."

Nabil Sharaf Al-Din: "Exactly."



 

Latest Clips More >
Latest Reports More >
Indian Writer B. Raman Blames U.S. Policy for Militant Activities in China's Xinjiang Province, Says: 'The Jamaat-e-Islami of Pakistan Contributes Money Regularly to the ETIM And Helps Many Uighur Students in Pakistan'
Special Dispatch - No. 4488 - February 12, 2012

Urdu Daily: Chinese Military Taking Over Gilgit Baltistan, Pakistan Considering Proposal to Lease the Disputed Region to China for 50 Years
Inquiry & Analysis Series Report - No. 4487 - February 12, 2012

Muslim Brotherhood General Guide Muhammad Badi': Our Ultimate Goal, Establishing a Global Islamic Caliphate, Can Only Be Achieved Gradually and Without Coercion
Special Dispatch - No. 4486 - February 10, 2012

Egyptian Cleric Mazen Sirsawi in Favor of Killing Apostates: 'Beheading Them Should Be Easier than Cutting the Buttons off Their Shirts'; 'If [the Holocaust] Really Happened, [the Jews] Deserved it'; 'The People of Truth Should Lie in Wait for the People of Falsehood'
Special Dispatch - No. 4485 - February 10, 2012

Al-Qaeda Leader Ayman Al-Zawahiri Announces Somali Al-Shabab Al-Mujahideen Officially Joined Al-Qaeda
Special Dispatch - No. 4484 - February 10, 2012

Muslim Clerics: Cyber Warfare against Israel Is a Form of Jihad
Special Dispatch - No. 4483 - February 9, 2012

Global March to Jerusalem: Speakers at Jamaat-e-Islami Pakistan Conference Claim That Mosques in Jerusalem and Medina are 'Under Direct Threat of Jewish Designs'
Special Dispatch - No. 4482 - February 9, 2012

Second-Tier Al-Qaeda Activists Embrace Twitter for Online Jihad: The Case of the Ansarullah Blog
Inquiry & Analysis Series Report - No. 798 - February 9, 2012

British Islamist Anjem Choudary Launches 'Shariah for India,' Vows to Demolish Hindu Temples and Bollywood; Muslims Urged to Join In New Delhi March Next Month Marking 88th Anniversary of the End of Islamic Caliphate
Inquiry & Analysis Series Report - No. 797 - February 9, 2012

Pro-Assad and Syrian Opposition Activists Come To Blows On Al-Jazeera TV
Special Dispatch - No. 4481 - February 8, 2012